| Month | Game | + | Away | Pitcher | At | Home | Pitcher |
| September | 1 | CHI | Tyler Anderson* | At | NYY | Tom Koehler | |
| September | 2 | CHI | Masahiro Tanaka | At | NYY | Jhoulys Chacin | |
| September | 3 | CHI | Tyler Chatwood | At | NYY | Trevor Bauer | |
| September | 4 | NYY | Carlos Martinez | At | CAL | Matt Moore* | |
| September | 5 | NYY | Matt Shoemaker | At | CAL | Patrick Corbin* | |
| September | 6 | NYY | Tom Koehler | At | CAL | Andrew Cashner | |
| September | OFF | ||||||
| September | 7 | + | BZZ | Jered Weaver | At | NYY | Jhoulys Chacin |
| September | 8 | + | BZZ | A.J. Griffin | At | NYY | Trevor Bauer |
| September | 9 | + | BZZ | Mike Leake | At | NYY | Carlos Martinez |
| September | 10 | + | BZZ | Yovani Gallardo | At | NYY | Matt Shoemaker |
| September | 11 | + | BZZ | Wily Peralta | At | NYY | Tom Koehler |
| September | 12 | + | NYY | Jhoulys Chacin | At | AAR | C.C. Sabathia* |
| September | 13 | + | NYY | Trevor Bauer | At | AAR | Noah Syndergaard |
| September | 14 | + | NYY | Carlos Martinez | At | AAR | R.A. Dickey |
| September | 15 | + | NYY | Matt Shoemaker | At | AAR | Yu Darvish |
| September | OFF | ||||||
| September | 16 | + | YDR | J.A. Happ* | At | NYY | Tom Koehler |
| September | 17 | + | YDR | Anthony Desclafani | At | NYY | Collin McHugh |
| September | 18 | + | YDR | Tanner Roark | At | NYY | Trevor Bauer |
| September | 19 | + | YDR | Chris Devenski | At | NYY | Carlos Martinez |
| September | 20 | + | YDR | Gerrit Cole | At | NYY | Matt Shoemaker |
| September | 21 | + | NYY | Tom Koehler | At | OAK | Williams Perez |
| September | 22 | + | NYY | Collin McHugh | At | OAK | Eduardo Rodriguez* |
| September | 23 | + | NYY | Trevor Bauer | At | OAK | Christian Friedrich* |
| September | 24 | + | NYY | Carlos Martinez | At | OAK | Zack Greinke |
| + Indicates In Division Game | |||||||