| Month | Game | + | Away | Pitcher | At | Home | Pitcher |
| September | 1 | NYY | Yovani Gallardo | At | SRD | Gavin Floyd | |
| September | 2 | NYY | Chris Sale* | At | SRD | Alexander Colome | |
| September | 3 | NYY | Randall Delgado | At | SRD | Tyler Matzek* | |
| September | 4 | CHI | Tim Hudson | At | NYY | Yordano Ventura | |
| September | 5 | CHI | Scott Feldman | At | NYY | Dan Haren | |
| September | 6 | CHI | Matt Cain | At | NYY | Yovani Gallardo | |
| September | OFF | ||||||
| September | 7 | DYE | Felix Hernandez | At | NYY | Chris Sale* | |
| September | 8 | DYE | Zack Wheeler | At | NYY | Randall Delgado | |
| September | 9 | DYE | Jesse Chavez | At | NYY | Aaron Harang | |
| September | 10 | NYY | Dan Haren | At | SYI | John Lackey | |
| September | 11 | NYY | Yovani Gallardo | At | SYI | Henderson Alvarez | |
| September | 12 | NYY | Chris Sale* | At | SYI | Hyun-Jin Ryu* | |
| September | 13 | CRC | Stephen Strasburg | At | NYY | Randall Delgado | |
| September | 14 | CRC | Mat Latos | At | NYY | Yordano Ventura | |
| September | 15 | CRC | Jorge De La Rosa* | At | NYY | Dan Haren | |
| September | OFF | ||||||
| September | 16 | + | NYY | Yovani Gallardo | At | NIM | Zack Greinke |
| September | 17 | + | NYY | Chris Sale* | At | NIM | Jonathon Niese* |
| September | 18 | + | NYY | Randall Delgado | At | NIM | Drew Hutchison |
| September | 19 | + | NYY | Colin McHugh | At | NIM | Masahiro Tanaka |
| September | 20 | + | NYY | Dan Haren | At | NIM | Zack Greinke |
| September | 21 | + | HEP | Tom Koehler | At | NYY | Yovani Gallardo |
| September | 22 | + | HEP | Jason Hammel | At | NYY | Chris Sale* |
| September | 23 | + | HEP | Charlie Morton | At | NYY | Randall Delgado |
| September | 24 | + | HEP | Samuel Deduno | At | NYY | Aaron Harang |
| + Indicates In Division Game | |||||||